This fall, I discovered an apple crisp recipe by Ina Garten (the Barefoot Contessa). I made it twice, the first time pretty much following the recipe exactly except for a slight increase in apples to accommodate a different size pan. The topping was outstanding, but the filling was a bit mushy and too citrusy. The second time, I reduced the citrus and used half Granny Smith apples and half Gala, decreasing the sugar slightly due to the sweetness of the Galas. This improved the flavor of the filling, and though it was one of the best apple crisps I've ever eaten, the filling was still too soft. The next time, I'll try baking at a higher temperature for less time and/or cutting the baking time and broiling the top, to try to keep the apples a bit more together while still browning the crisp.
For those that want to try the recipe, the changes I made were as follows:
- Use half tart, crisp apples (e.g., Granny Smith) and half sweet, crisp apples (e.g., Gala)
- Use only the zest of half an orange (no lemon zest)
- Use only 1 Tbsp. lemon juice (no orange juice)
- Decrease sugar to 3/8 cup
- Decrease nutmeg to 1/2 teaspoon (mainly this is because I don't care for nutmeg)
- Bake in 13x9 rectangular baking dish